Agent at Lantern Residential
Local business · Winthrop, MALocal business · 82 Jefferson St, Winthrop, MA 02152, USA
Verified record
Most of the people who have written about Jenny Golic were buying their first home — and a striking number of them ended up in houses that were never publicly listed. She works out of Winthrop under the Lantern Residential brokerage, which her own site states, and her Massachusetts real estate licence is registry-verified active in her own name. The site lists coverage well beyond Winthrop: Boston, Marblehead, Hingham, Medford, Swampscott, Scituate, Weymouth, Wellesley, Newton, Braintree, Brighton, Quincy, Newbury and Newburyport. The specifics are where this gets interesting. In a February 2026 review, a couple described selling their condo in a soft market and getting an offer over asking, then buying their next home with what they called a creative offer that beat other bidders. Reviews posted in January 2026 come from first-time buyers: one recounted a March 2025 search across Winthrop and the South Shore that ended in an off-market house; another wrote that she quarterbacked an off-market purchase and negotiated roughly ten percent off the asking price. Reviewers writing in 2024 tell a similar story — one credited her connections for early looks at homes before they listed, another said she never pushed them to waive contingencies or bid on a house they did not love. One thing to weigh: all twelve of those reviews sit on Google, and the written history only begins in 2024. Every one is five stars. That is a real base, but a narrow one, and it says more about how she handles a search than about how she handles a deal that falls apart. If you are buying your first place around Greater Boston and want an agent working the pre-market and off-market channel rather than just the listings everyone else sees, she is a sensible first call. Ask what she has actually closed in your specific town in the last year, and whether her current work leans toward buyers or sellers.
Jenny is absolutely fantastic at what she does. She helped us both sell our condo and buy our new home. We thought selling in a down market was going to be tough, but Jenny worked hard to get us a solid offer - OVER asking. She knew how to market our place to bring in the right buyers. Jenny was also amazing at helping us navigate the home buying process. She knew what we wanted and helped us with a creative offer that beat out other potential buyers. Jenny is such a hard worker and she’s pretty fun to hang out with, too - there’s no one else out there I’d want representing me in the buying or selling process.
Jenny was absolutely amazing to work with! She found us our very first home, and it truly feels perfect in every way. From the start, she was so thoughtful, personable, and responsive—it never felt like we were just working with a realtor, but with a friend who genuinely cared about us. As first‑time homebuyers, we had a lot of questions, and Jenny guided us through every step with patience and kindness. She was quick to find us the right home and made the whole process feel so much easier and less stressful. We’re beyond grateful for her and couldn’t recommend her more highly!
We are so grateful to have worked with Jenny! She found us our very first home, and it is truly perfect in every way. She is incredibly thoughtful, personable, and responsive—always a joy to work with. As first‑time homebuyers, she guided us through the process with patience and clarity, making everything feel less overwhelming. She was quick to find us the right home in such a short amount of time and supported us every step of the way. We couldn’t recommend her more highly!
Jenny was our best decision of 2025! Without her knowledge, unwavering energy, HONESTY, and amazing sense of humor, we would not have landed in our dream house. We started working with Jenny as first-time homebuyers in March 2025, and she guided us through countless home visits during our search (which was all over Winthrop / South Shore). She devoted so much of her time to debrief each viewing with us afterwards, and stayed incredibly responsive to our questions and communication as we decided next steps. The house we ended up buying was actually off market, but it was thanks to Jenny that we learned this; she persistently and patiently reached out to the seller’s agent to find out more information for us. She coached us through the negotiation process until our bid was accepted (!) Jenny completely met us where we were at as first-time homebuyers, and went above and beyond by providing us with quality recommendations for our mortgage lender, inspector, contract lawyer, and contractor. It is so important to have an agent like Jenny by your side as you navigate the housing market. We are immensely grateful for her passion and personality. Thank you, Jenny!
My wife and I are incredibly lucky to have found and worked with Jenny. We’re first time home buyers and we weren’t sure if we’d be able to buy a suitable house in today’s market. Jenny helped us do just that. She quarterbacked our purchase of a home that was off market, while negotiating the asking price down to by ~10%. Jenny also helped guide and educate us through the entire buying process. She was patient, knowledgeable and extremely responsive no matter the question or time of day. We frequented open houses with her across multiple towns. She was always willing to travel and made each showing enjoyable and would provide her honest feedback without hesitation. It’s also no surprise that Jenny’s network is incredible. We had to move quickly in the purchase process and were able to trust the folks she referred to us without worry. We ended up signing our P&S agreement two days before Christmas with her help. We’ve recommended Jenny to our closest friends and family for a reason.
Specializes in
Also offers
Service area
Languages
Added 12 new comments, added 23 new photos, verified active license, established rating 4.0
4.4140 reviews
4.4132 reviews
4.4106 reviews
4.472 reviews